Craigslist Idaho Cars For Sale By Owner (2025)

FAQs

How effective is Craigslist for selling cars? ›

Getting your inventory listed on Craigslist is one of the most profitable ways to advertise your cars. It's proven that car buyers on Craigslist tend to convert much quicker than on any other classifieds. The conversion rate on Craigslist can be as high as 10%, and that's huge.

When posting items for sale on Craigslist, you should always: Avoid adding any personal information in the posting, including your name, real phone number or real email address.

Rest assured, though, that the exchange of the VIN is a normal, legitimate part of used car selling and is usually the best option. Giving out your VIN is one of the best ways for a buyer to see that your car isn't hiding any nasty surprises for them.

To identify a scam listing on Craigslist, look for these red flags: prices that are too good to be true, vague or generic item descriptions, poor grammar and spelling in the listing, a sense of urgency to complete the transaction, and requests for personal information or unconventional payment methods.

Craiglist Safety Tips for Sellers

Request cash payment when exchanging in person. If you're shipping your item, use a service such as PayPal for more security. Never accept a money order; this is usually a scam. Cashier's checks can be forged, so exercise caution when accepting these.

How long do paid automotive listings last? A. 30 days.